By: Katelynn Robinson & Vanni Chawla
Imagine you are a young adult accused of a crime you did not commit. A jury finds you guilty of the crime, and you
are sentenced to spend most of your life in jail. Years, or even decades, pass as you sit in a small cell, and life within
prison walls gradually changes you until you no longer recognize the person you once were. This might sound
unlikely, but there are approximately 20,000 wrongfully convicted people experiencing this nightmare in American
prisons today.
In an attempt to chip away at this problem, a few public interest lawyers around the nation have created programs to provide post-conviction relief to incarcerated innocent people. Since 1999, San Diego has been home to one of them, the California Innocence Project (CIP).
CIP began when attorney Justin Brooks, represented a 21-year-old woman who was sentenced to death on a
plea bargain. Brooks was a professor at California Western School of Law (CWSL) and believed in her innocence. He
commissioned a team of students to conduct research in support of a writ of habeas corpus. Brooks and his team
won, and the woman was released from prison. This case inspired Brooks to establish the CIP, and the California
Western School of Law began offering students the opportunity to participate in the CIP as a clinical program.
Over the years, CIP students have benefitted from hands-on legal training, developed critical thinking skills, and learned about criminal justice reform.
Attorney Michael Semanchik, formerly of CWSL’s CIP program, is currently the Executive Director of The
Innocence Center. He explains that when innocence work began in the 1990s, students were vital participants in the
post-conviction relief process. Semanchik said that students would “go out in the field, go out to the prison and interview their client, track down witnesses, and try to see if there was any evidence of innocence that they could come up with.” Over the years, Semanchik said, funding for innocence work increased, and the need for student volunteers decreased.
But, he maintained, there is value in shaping young lawyers.
The CIP program drew law school applicants to CWSL, and many decided to attend the school, hoping to participate in the clinic. 3L Hunter Rohde interned at the CIP as an undergraduate at the University of San Diego. After applying to law school, Rohde “was going to make USD work, but after that experience at the California Innocence Project, [she] thought Cal Western was a really awesome option.” “Without the CIP experience, I would have ended up at USD,” Rohde said.
CWSL students report that participation in the CIP enhanced their educational experience and their credentials. 2L Meenal Patel found that her experience working at a law firm did not provide the depth of experience that the CIP offered. As a CIP participant, Patel said she prepared weekly memos and presentations and participated in deciding whether a potential client had a viable case. Patel felt like a valued member of the team. “The attorneys took into account what I really thought,” Patel said. She also learned about the need for reforms. “[CIP] shows you that our system needs a lot of revamping. . . you can see that mistakes have been made. . . little things that were overlooked that change the trajectory of someone’s life. It raises a lot of questions.” Patel was deeply moved after meeting a person who was exonerated. “To see how much life they lost…it is important to mitigate those mistakes,” Patel said.
Rohde agreed, saying, “Above all else, you . . . get to help people who are . . . at the end of the line in terms of hope and the ability to help themselves.” Rohde also described how her CIP experience impacted her job search. “I was
asked about the Innocence Project on every single [job] interview I had,” Rohde said. “It looks good [on a resume]
because you are getting an opportunity that you don’t get anywhere else.”
By 2023, CIP students and attorneys had filed writs of habeas corpus, resulting in 40 innocent people returning
to life outside the correctional system. The CIP program was thriving.
In May 2023, things began to change. Brooks transitioned to a staff position at the University of San Diego, and several other staff members moved on from the CIP.
Shortly thereafter, CWSL made headlines. The headlines caused confusion about the status of the program, but
CWSL maintains that its innocence work never “shut down.” CWSL President and Dean Sean M. Scott explained, “It is
a clinical program at CWSL and can only be shuttered by the law school or its accrediting body, the American Bar
Association (‘ABA’). Neither the law school nor the ABA ‘shut down’ the program.”
The school also lost permission to use the “Innocence Project” name, raising questions.
Dean Scott responded, “Some, but not all, organizations engaged in innocence work chose to use the phrase
‘Innocence Project’ in their name. Use of the phrase requires a license from the national Innocence Project.” According to Dean Scott, the school lost the license to use the name due to a lack of staff and a faculty director, but the school is committed to continuing its innocence work.
Students were distressed about the uncertainty. Patel remembers that her fall 2023 CIP experience started off
well, but that changed in November. Patel said, “That is when things were getting chaotic. We weren’t aware of
what was happening with the project.” Rohde agreed, stating, “We didn’t really understand why the decision to
slow the project down was being made.”
Roque, a 1L who aspires to do post-conviction innocence work after she graduates, enrolled at CWSL because of
the CIP program. She eagerly applied to participate in the program and was in touch with some of its leaders. Like
others, when the news broke, she thought CIP was closing. Roque said she was “in complete shock” and felt “robbed of an opportunity.”

“It broke my heart,” Roque said.
Some students were troubled about the academic impacts of the suspension. Patel explained, “We didn’t know how
to plan out our course schedule. It led to a lot of confusion for us.” Had she known about the changes in advance,
Patel said she “would have applied to a lot more places for internships in the spring . . . [she] missed opportunities
and was limited in what [she] could apply for.” Rohde was concerned about registering for enough credits.
To lead CIP through a transition period, CWSL selected Alissa Bjerkhoel as CIP Interim Director. Soon after Bjerkhoel was selected, Governor Gavin Newsom appointed her to a position on the bench, again leaving the CIP without a director.
Without anyone to lead CIP, California Innocence Advocates (Cal-IA) and Professor Megan Baca stepped
forward to offer a solution. Baca founded Cal-IA, staffed by experienced innocence attorneys who formerly led an
innocence clinic at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles. CalIA differs from other California Innocence organizations in
that it maintains a small caseload with the aim of resolving cases more quickly and giving incarcerated clients’ cases the attention they deserve.
Baca said that Cal-IA contacted CWSL and created a partnership to “sort through the cases and contact clients
and potential clients to bring some clarity to the changes.” In January 2024, Baca took on the role of Interim Director. “We are grateful,” Dean Scott said, “Professor Baca has already engaged CWSL students in ongoing innocence work.” According to Baca, progress has been made. “In the past three months, we have done an initial review of nearly 1,000 cases and contacted each incarcerated individual. We have narrowed these cases to approximately 300 qualifying cases and approximately 20 priority cases.”
In fact, as recently as April 4, 2024, the CWSL/Cal-IA partnership helped Wesner Charles, Jr., who spent 22 years
in prison for a crime he did not commit, regain his freedom. Under Baca’s leadership, CWSL will offer its innocence
clinic to students during the summer for the first time. Baca described the proposed program experience as follows: “Students will partake in case evaluations, filing and arguing motions in court, investigation, drafting of petitions for writ of habeas corpus, litigation, and assisting the clients with re-entry efforts.”
CWSL’s innocence work will continue to evolve, giving students the benefit of real-life experience. Professor Amy
Kimpel will start leading the CIP program in July 2024. Kimpel has over 14 years of experience in the criminal
defense arena. She worked in California for many years, including as a federal defender and at the Judicial Council of California in the Criminal Justice Services Office. For the last five years, she has been leading a criminal defense clinic at the University of Alabama School of Law.
Dean Scott expressed confidence in Kimpel, stating, “Professor Kimpel will provide exemplary leadership to
help us better serve our primary mission of educating law students. And, of course, the clinic will continue its legal
work to free those who have been wrongfully convicted, involving law students every step of the way.” Scott noted,
“Staff and faculty changes are an inevitable part of life at any law school or institution of higher education. While the faces may look different, the important innocence work we are doing will continue.”
Kimpel says she enjoys the dual role of practicing law and training new attorneys. Looking forward to her position
at CWSL, Kimpel said she plans to meet with Brooks and others who built up the CIP practice and community of
volunteers when she arrives.
Students have raised concerns about reducing the number of cases the clinic will process. “It isn’t the number of cases; it is the quality of those experiences,” Kimpel responded, “How much ownership do you have over an investigation and a hearing and a motion?” She said, “[Students] will draft the motions, and I will give feedback. I think you learn more by being in the driver’s seat, . . . I am looking to my students to direct litigation, obviously with supervision. I want to provide … opportunities to take ownership. You can have
more experience regardless of the volume.”
Kimpel is excited about returning to California. She plans to share her passion for representing defendants and
training law students. She says what she enjoys most about being a clinic professor is “be[ing] there to see
[students] develop skills as a lawyer. To see them as they have those first victories. When they help draft a motion
that helped free someone, it is pretty powerful.”
